Queer athletes are ignored and silenced

Karate instructor María Helga Guðmundsdóttir thinks it’s important to open up a discussion on queer prejudice and bullying in sports in Iceland and has posted about it on Facebook. Halla Þórlaug Óskarsdóttir met María Helga and started by asking what prompted her to speak up.

María Helga Guðmundsdóttir is a geologist, a translator and an instructor at Þórshamar karate club. She has practiced karate since childhood and coached for several years in Reykjavík.
María Helga Guðmundsdóttir is a geologist, a translator, an instructor at Þórshamar Karate Club and a member of the national karate team. She has practiced karate since childhood and coached for several years in Reykjavík. Photo by Anubha Anushree.

“Well, I was having dinner at a karate training camp in Europe, where some pretty typical generic homophobic remarks were being made at the table. One guy was saying something and another guy kept saying: “Oh, that’s so gay”, even though they didn’t mean anything by it.

But it kind of struck me, that these are the sort of things people tend to say without thinking that there might actually be people present who are queer. That people saying these things might be pushing young people, who look at them as role models, deeper into the closet.

That got me thinking that even in a place like Iceland where queer issues are openly discussed, they’re not discussed in sports at all.

For example there’s a whole section on preventing bullying and discouraging substance abuse on the website of ÍSÍ (The National Olympic and Sports Association of Iceland), but there is no mention of the words queer or gay – let alone trans. That’s why I began thinking: why are we not discussing this? So I figured the best way to do that was just to open my mouth and start talking.”

Asked if she’s experienced or witnessed queer prejudice in sports in Iceland María Helga says that she’s familiar with incidents where coaches and athletes have demonstrated clear prejudice. “A friend of mine has also experienced attitudes towards queer women in basketball. She told me that hate speech is rare, but erasure and silence are common. For example her coach would always refer to her and her girlfriend as sisters. And, then the younger girls were insecure about showering with players who were lesbians, but it was never brought up, never dealt with openly.”

“A friend of mine has experienced attitudes towards queer women in basketball. She told me that … erasure and silence are common.”

Is queer prejudice more common in certain sports? “Well, the main difference is how homophobia is expressed in team sports versus individual sports. I think it’s definitely true that whenever you bond with a team, it certainly reinforces a certain way of presenting yourself and discourages you from deviating from whichever way you’ve chosen to put yourself forward.

Whereas when you’re competing as an individual you have a little bit more flexibility to change the way you present yourself without somehow disturbing the dynamic of the group.

And we do see in some of the most popular organized team sports, like professional soccer for instance. I read somewhere that out of about 500.000 professional male soccer players in the world, historically maybe three have been out, while playing. That says a lot.

You basically don’t need mild or egregious homophobic slurs to make the environment unfriendly. If you are a queer person and have no role models in sports, like in soccer where there are no openly gay guys, it doesn’t exactly make for a friendly environment to start with.”

Trans phobia and intersex phobia in sports

María Helga says that homophobia isn’t the only problem in the world of sports, there is also tremendous anxiety surrounding gender identity and biological sex. “For example, there has been a practice for decades now of gender testing female athletes who compete in women’s sports’ categories,” she points out. “Nominally this is meant to ensure that men don’t pretend to be women to gain a competitive advantage in sports, but the effect is basically to police femininity in these environments and to humiliate women, from women who have atypical hormonal production, to intersex women who have chromosomal variations.

South African athlete Caster Semenya was cleared to continue competing as a woman after gender testing by the IAAF (International Association of Athletics Federations). "It was upsetting, you feel humiliated...If it wasn't for my family, I don't think I could have survived," she said in an interview with BBC, when recalling the incident that saw her forced to undergo a series of gender verification tests, news of which was made public by athletics' governing body,
South African athlete Caster Semenya was cleared to continue competing as a woman after gender testing by the IAAF (International Association of Athletics Federations) in Berlin, Germany in 2009. “It was upsetting, you feel humiliated…If it wasn’t for my family, I don’t think I could have survived,” she later said in an interview with BBC, when recalling the incident that saw her forced to undergo a series of gender verification tests, news of which was made public by athletics’ governing body. Photo by Citizen59.

There have been cases of athletes who have been banned from competing because they turned out to have XY chromosomes but they had complete androgen insensitivity and therefore derived no competitive advantage from their supposed male biological status.

And at no point in history has anyone ever uncovered a case of sex fraud for competitive benefits in sports, so it’s pretty clear that the anxiety on which this is based is completely unfounded.

And in light of that I think trans athletes are really having a tough time.”

Abroad there seem to be two groups with opposing views; one that supports the rights of trans people to compete in sports and another that for example believes that trans women have an unfair advantage in various sports. Do you think there’s a way to compromise their views?
“I think it’s always possible to come up with a set of rules that ensure opportunity and a reasonably level playing field. But I think we also need to be conscious of the fact that although we talk about a level playing, that’s essentially just a fantasy. There is no such thing. We are all differently able physically, and whatever set of rules we impose, they’re always going to advantage some people over others.

For example the NCAA, which is the main college athletics association in the US, has a very detailed policy on trans athletes. They have taken steps to ensure that their policy is in a place to allow both trans female and male athletes to compete in appropriate male or female categories of their choosing.

“There has been a practice for decades now of gender testing female athletes … to humiliate women, from women who have atypical hormonal production, to intersex women …”

Basically the only criteria that are required is that there has to be a disclosure of hormonal treatments, and that trans female athletes who are not receiving hormone replacements can not compete in female categories because they’re considered to have testosterone advantage and trans male athletes can not compete in female categories if they are receiving testosterone.

When asked María Helga says that she’s unaware of any genetic tests’ being performed on Icelandic athletes. “Hormone levels are monitored as a part of standard drug tests, but as far as I understand the international rules followed by ÍSÍ (Iceland’s National Olympic and Sports Association), they take into consideration whether an athlete has previously been found to have naturally high testosterone levels” she says, referring to article Article 7.4 which says: The “required investigation” described in this Article will depend on the situation. For example, if it has previously determined that an Athlete has a naturally elevated testosterone/epitestosterone ratio, confirmation that an Atypical Finding is consistent with that prior ratio is a sufficient investigation.”
When asked María Helga says that she’s unaware of any genetic tests’ being performed on Icelandic athletes. “Hormone levels are monitored as a part of standard drug tests, but as far as I understand the international rules followed by ÍSÍ (Iceland’s National Olympic and Sports Association), they take into consideration whether an athlete has previously been found to have naturally high testosterone levels” she says, referring to Article 7.4 which says: The “required investigation” described in this Article will depend on the situation. For example, if it has previously determined that an Athlete has a naturally elevated testosterone/epitestosterone ratio, confirmation that an Atypical Finding is consistent with that prior ratio is a sufficient investigation.”

Apart from that they’ve put together a policy that, as far as I can tell as a non-expert, makes great strives towards ensuring that trans athletes have the rights to participate in sports; the right to express their gender identity and be treated with respect in accordance with that.

So it’s not impossible, it’s just a matter of sitting down, drawing up some sound rules and educating people on how to treat each other with respect.

And as for the supposed advantage that trans women have when competing in female categories, it’s generally accepted based on scientific studies that after a year of hormone replacement, changes in muscle mass and strength have closed the gap between them and “biologically born females”. So, a trans woman who has been receiving hormone replacement for over a year has no physical advantage over “an average woman”, due to a greater testosterone supply.”

When you say it’s important to open up a discussion on queer prejudice in sports in Iceland, how do you think that should be carried out? 
“I believe it all starts and ends with education. At karate club, for example, we have a courses for new coaches, where we address this issue. Two members of our board are queer – myself and Kitty Anderson, president of Intersex Iceland and board member at Samtökin ‘78 – so we didn’t have to look far for motivation to bring these matters to the fore. We are working on a formal education package dealing with queer issues in sports, which could be shared with other organizations, but in the meantime we keep the subject very much open with our coaches and young athletes. Most if not all of them read the Facebook post that prompted this interview, and we’ve had very productive conversations about it at the club.

“I think ÍSÍ should set the tone over all and then the sports clubs need to follow-up. The sports movement needs to be less afraid to talk about these things.”

But I think ÍSÍ should set the tone over all and then the sports clubs should follow-up. The sports movement needs to be less afraid to talk about these things. A lot of queer athletes probably keep their mouths shut for far a longer time than they have to, because they’ve experienced enough prejudice in their lifetimes and they don’t want to invite more.

We often tend to make an instinctive choice to be silent, because opening up makes us anxious, and I don’t think we have to. We need to recognize that it’s not as dangerous as we’d like to think.

I also think that the more people are out, the less likely others are to make inappropriate or hurtful comments, because all of a sudden there’s a real human being with a real face in front of them whose feelings could be hurt.

I’m sure none of the people I was talking to at the training camp, would have made those comments if they knew there was for example a gay guy at the table. Because in reality, they’re nice people.”

 “I think the sports scene is a really important place for young people to express themselves and grow and learn what they’re capable of. My karate club was kind of like my third parent when I was growing up; I spent most of my free time there, and the people who taught me there were my mentors and role models and made a huge influence on how my attitudes towards certain things in life were shaped. If kids feel insecure about their own sexuality and those insecurities are reinforced through either silence or outrage ____?,” says María Helga, here With students and fellow athletes before traveling to the Swedish Open in March 2015.
“I think the sports scene is a really important place for young people to express themselves and grow and learn what they’re capable of. My karate club was kind of like my third parent when I was growing up; I spent most of my free time there, and the people who taught me there were my mentors and role models and made a huge impact on how my attitudes towards certain things in life were shaped. If kids who feel insecure about their own sexuality or their gender identity have those insecurities reinforced through either silence or offensice remarks in their environment, then we are failing those kids as role models and mentors,” says María Helga, here with students and fellow athletes before traveling to the Swedish Open in March 2015.

See also: ÍSÍ has to fight homophobia

Main photo: Birkir Jónsson.

Á. Óskarsson
Á. Óskarsson

Á. Óskarsson offers a variety of products and services to sports centers, swimming pools, schools, kindergartens, and the general public. The company specializes in sport-related products, activity-focused games, and a wide range of solutions for sports facilities.

Á. Óskarsson has been involved in numerous big projects related to building sports facilities and has made it their benchmark to offer good quality products and equipment since the company was founded.

See links to social media in the upper left-hand corner

—————-

Á. Óskarsson selur fjölbreytt vöruúrval fyrir íþróttahús, sundlaugar, skóla og leikskóla og einnig ýmsar vörur til einkaafnota. Fyrirtækið selur vörur til íþróttaiðkunnar og leikja ásamt því að bjóða upp á ýmsar lausnir fyrir íþróttamannvirki.

Á. Óskarsson hefur komið að fjölda stórra verkefna við byggingu íþróttamannvirkja og hefur frá stofnun kappkostað að bjóða vandaðar og endingargóðar vörur.

Tenglar á samfélagsmiðla eru í efra horninu vinstra megin.

Webpage/vefsetur

Blush

    Blush was founded in 2011 when it started selling high quality sex products. The goal from the beginning was to change the market and take the discussion about sex products to a higher level. Today Blush provides professional services in a pleasant environment that fulfills different needs, both for individuals and couples. Blush respects diversity and wants to set a good example in all of its messaging to target audiences. Sexual health and equality in sex is important and Blush wants to focus on those issues through education and open discussion. Blush works in a socially responsible manner for society, their customers and the environment.

    Check out Blush’s website: https://blush.is/

    Omnom Chocolate
    - award-winning chocolate maker

      Omnom Chocolate is an Icelandic craft chocolate company based in Reykjavík. We produce handcrafted chocolate from organic cacao beans sourced ethically and sustainably. We’ve developed direct relationships to create premium chocolate with fine flavor cacao beans.

      Our creative flavors are carefully crafted by meticulous chocolate makers. The cacao beans are roasted, winnowed, ground, and refined into melty-smooth chocolate.

      Omnom’s process is one of constant exploration, invention, and experimentation. If it doesn’t please us, if something isn’t absolutely delicious, there’s no reason to be doing it. So, we always start with our taste buds and follow our instincts. Our team searches for the finest ingredients in the world and new ways to improve chocolate. This obsession with knowing where our ingredients come from has led us around the corner to dairy farms in the Icelandic countryside and all the way to rainforest cacao farms of Nicaragua.

      In only a few short years, we’ve grown from our 50 sq. m. petrol station space and become an award-winning chocolate maker. Now, with our headquarters in 101 Reykjavík, our chocolate is sent out around Iceland and all over the world.

      At the end of the day, our goal is to make chocolate.

       

      Nasdaq

         

        Nasdaq (Nasdaq: NDAQ) is a global technology company serving the capital markets and other industries. Our diverse offering of data, analytics, software and services enables clients to optimize and execute their business vision with confidence.

        With over 4,300 employees in 39 offices around the world, at Nasdaq we all contribute to the success of the company and its culture, and each one of us has the ability to make a difference. When it comes to our core mission and values, we embrace the role of Diversity, Inclusion and Belonging (DIB) as a fundamental driver of our corporate growth, workplace culture and market development. We strive to create a culture that embraces the power of different perspectives—a culture where people’s unique backgrounds and different experiences helps us fuel innovation and support our clients around the world.

        Our unique position at the center of the capital markets allows us to see firsthand how these values have redefined corporate culture and success, deepening and accelerating our own commitment to champion inclusive growth and prosperity, as we strive to create more equitable opportunities to help people of all backgrounds reach their full potential. Most notably, we published our diversity statistics for the first time in 2020. These metrics serve as a quantitative assessment of where we are today and help determine what strategies we need to adopt to enhance diversity in the workplace. We recognize that we have much work to do, but we are steadfast in our commitment to creating a diverse and inclusive culture—one that reflects the communities in which we live, allows all employees to be their true, authentic selves and fosters individual growth and achievement.

        As we move forward together, we will continue advancing diverse ideas and perspectives that help fulfill the promise of a more inclusive and prosperous world. We aim to set the pace for rethinking capital markets and economies anywhere and everywhere. To learn more about the company, technology solutions and career opportunities, visit us on LinkedIn, on Twitter @Nasdaq, or at www.nasdaq.com.

        Blue Lagoon
        - One of the 25 Wonders of the World

        Named by National Geographic as one of the 25 Wonders of the World, the Blue Lagoon is a shimmering expanse of warmth, relaxation, and rejuvenation. Its unique geothermal seawater
        comes from 2.000 meters within the earth where seawater and freshwater converge in a tectonic realm of porous lava and searing heat. Propelled by extreme pressure, the water ascends to the earth’s surface, emerging enriched with silica, algae, and minerals—the elements that endow Blue Lagoon geothermal seawater with its radiant, healing properties.

        From its humble beginnings in the shadows of a geothermal power plant, Blue Lagoon has evolved into a world of wonder, now encompassing two hotels, three restaurants, three
        geothermal lagoons, a subterranean spa, a renowned line of skin care, a thriving research center, and a wealth of spa and refreshment facilities.

        Achieving harmony with the volcanic landscape, the lagoon and its surrounding architecture embody the unification of the man-made and the natural, and adhere to the highest principles of sustainability.

        The Blue Lagoon. A wonder of the world. A world of wonder.

        Landsbankinn
        - leading financial institution
        Landsbankinn

        Landsbankinn is a leading Icelandic financial institution. It offers a full range of financial services and is the market leader in the Icelandic financial service sector with the largest branch network.

        The present bank was established on 7 October 2008 but the history of its predecessor dates back to 1886. The bank is owned by the National Treasury of Iceland, which holds 98.2% of its share capital, and other shareholders who own 1.8%.

        Landsbankinn’s strategy is to provide comprehensive financial services that meet customer’s needs. It emphasizes providing exemplary service to customers, developing e-banking for their convenience, increasing the efficiency of support functions, modernizing its technology and ensuring effective utilization of its balance sheet.

        The bank’s vision is to be exemplary and its role is to be a trusted financial partner.

        Special emphasis is placed on promoting a performance-oriented culture in the bank. To follow up on the implementation of this strategy, the bank has defined key goals which are measured regularly to determine progress. These goals include, for example, customer satisfaction and loyalty, profitability, cost efficiency and the correlation between risk appetite and employee satisfaction.

        Landsbankinn wishes to lead the development of a sustainable society in Iceland by integrating economic, social and environmental concerns in its operations. The Bank aims to ensure that both its owners and society at large benefit from its activities.

        It intends to achieve this aim by building solid infrastructure and a strong team of 1.100 employees, by listening to its customers and by respecting and encouraging its employees to actively participate in their community. Landsbankinn was a founding member of Festa, a Centre for Corporate Social Responsibility, and is a member of the UN Global Compact.

        Landsbankinn has been a proud sponsor of the Reykjavik Pride since it was first celebrated in Iceland.

        Dohop
        - get inspired
        Dohop

        Dohop allows people to find the cheapest flights available with just one click. Founded in Reykjavik in 2004, it is the only Icelandic company of its kind and quickly became the go-to tool for finding cheap flights among the locals. Dohop finds the best deals among hundreds of different airlines and online travel agencies, to make sure that the user is getting the cheapest price. Dohop also offers hotel and car rental search engines, so users can make all of their travel bookings from a single website.

        Dohop‘s specialty is finding so-called “self-connect” flight options, which can save travelers money by booking a ticket through two or more different airlines. The ability to look for these self-connect option is what sets Dohop apart from its competition, as it can save people hundreds of dollars on certain routes.

        More recently, Dohop has developed a unique product called Dohop Go!, which allows users to check for the cheapest available flights from their home airport. This tool is perfect for those who are looking for travel inspiration but are not willing to overpay for their flight ticket. Dohop Go! is now available in the Dohop Flights App, both for Android and iOS, along with its traditional flight, hotel, and car search engines. “

        VSÓ Ráðgjöf

           

          VSÓ Ráðgjöf er alhliða ráðgjafar- og verkfræðifyrirtæki sem leggur áherslu á trausta og faglega þjónustu sem tryggir viðskiptavinum hagkvæmustu lausnir hverju sinni, skilar raunverulegum árangri og stuðlar að samkeppnisforskoti.  Á skrifstofum VSÓ í Reykjavík og í Noregi starfar yfir 80 manna samhentur hópur verkfræðinga og annarra tæknimenntaðra starfsmanna.

          Macland
          - for all your Apple needs
          Macland

          From starting out as a proper startup with only a good idea and the need to change things, to becoming an established company with 6 employees. Starting from scratch and expanding organically has allowed us to love our expansion and take our customers on the ride with us.

          Macland is located at Laugavegur 23 (101, Downtown Reykjavik)
          For all your Apple needs. We are here.

          Ísey skyr
          - once tasted never forgotten

          Our Story
          Once upon a time, 1,100 years ago in fact, Nordic settlers began arriving in Iceland. They brought with them the skills and knowledge for producing skyr. As time passed, the know-how and recipe for this nutritious food slowly faded out elsewhere in the Nordic region. Luckily, the Icelandic skyr-making tradition continued.

          For centuries, Icelandic skyr formed a cornerstone of the national diet, helping to keep people strong in living conditions that were often harsh. On family farms countrywide, it was the women who nurtured this dairy and passing on both the recipe and the original Icelandic skyr cultures from mother to daughter.

          Ísey skyr builds on this remarkable legacy. It was some of those very same women, the recipients of their mothers’ expertise, who, around 90 years ago, taught Icelandic dairy scientists the art of skyr-making. The production process is more high-tech these days, and the quality standards more rigorous. However, the basic recipe and the use of original cultures to ferment the skimmed milk remain the same. Protein rich, fat-free, creamy and delicious – Ísey skyr is as relevant to consumers now as it was all those centuries ago.
          This is our secret and you are in on it

          You can read more about Ísey skyr on our website.

          Contact Us


          PGlmcmFtZSBzcmM9Imh0dHBzOi8vd3d3Lmdvb2dsZS5jb20vbWFwcy9lbWJlZD9wYj0hMW0xNCExbTEyITFtMyExZDI3ODQyLjM0NzA2NDA3OTU4ITJkLTIxLjkwMDg1MDg1NzkxODQyITNkNjQuMTQxNzA3ODE2NzAyMDEhMm0zITFmMCEyZjAhM2YwITNtMiExaTEwMjQhMmk3NjghNGYxMy4xITVlMCEzbTIhMXNlbiEycyE0djE0MzMzMzc5MTUyMjYiIHdpZHRoPSIxMDAlIiBoZWlnaHQ9IjEwMCUiIGZyYW1lYm9yZGVyPSIwIiBzdHlsZT0iYm9yZGVyOjAiPjwvaWZyYW1lPg==
          Thank You. We will contact you as soon as possible.